Monday, November 5, 2007

More Fieldnotes!

Note: All quotes from forum posts are [sic].

Because Wizard Rock is an unusually web-based scene, I’ve decided to focus my ethnography on the online Wrock community. As recommended to me by my commenters, I checked out the Wizard Rock forums at the HP Alliance (http://thehpalliance.org/). At the Fan Discussion forum (http://thehpalliance.org/phpBB/viewforum.php?f=22), one thread discusses good names for Wrock groups. Three posters say that while they would like to form bands, they’re not talented enough to do so, which suggests that there are some standards for talent in the Wizard Rock scene. One post suggests starting a rap group called the Hogwarts Homies. Poster Tonks22 says “I can’t rap…but maybe I can manage WRap?” to which poster Giant Squuidy responds with “Anything with that W in front of it is a whole different story! In the real rap world the Hogwarts Homies would be mocked for their lack of talent. but in the wrap world, they would be cherished!” Another poster said that she registered a Myspace account for a band she hasn’t started yet so that nobody would steal her name.

On a topic about The Remus Lupins, posters discuss the longevity of Wrock. They all agree that Wizard Rock will continue to be popular even though the Harry Potter series is over, though maybe not forever. Poster Nefret says “Wizard Rock is a lot like Dumbledore. It “will never be gone as long as were here” it’s “love is keeping us alive”” Giant Squuidy says “The fandom is totally something I’ll annoy my grandkids with. “Back in the day, we used to sing about BOOKS.”” While these fans accept that Wizard Rock may die out eventually as Harry Potter’s popularity wanes, they maintain that their affiliation with Wizard Rock will be a permanent part of their identities. There’s also a mention of how the The Remus Lupins had money and equipment stolen from their tour van. Fans are being encouraged to support the bands by buying their merchandise and donating money. After the theft, the website Wizardrock.org apparently donated half of what they made from selling merchandise to the band.

The thread “Wizard Rock stole my heart…Share your story!” discusses how fans learned about Wizard Rock and what it means to them. Two posters say that Harry and the Potters was their first Wizard Rock band, which makes sense as they have the most mainstream recognition out of any Wrock band, two posters say that they discovered Wizard Rock through online Harry Potter forums, and two posters specifically mention that they used Myspace pages to find new Wrock bands. Most of the posters include very passionate declarations about their connections to Wizard Rock: Phlogiston describes Wrock as “unprecedented love” and Gingeroot calls it “cathartic” and “love.” Nefret’s post reads “I was just talking about this today with someone, Wizard Rock has made me the person I am today. Because of Wizard Rock I am better able to deal with my anger management issues, I'm a more social person, I'm no longer afraid to sing in front of others, and I'm happy. Wizard Rock is one of the few things that is guaranteed to lift my mood. As cheesy as it sounds Wizard Rock has changed my life and made me a better person.” Dinahsaur, the original poster, says, “Now, four years after I first listened to Harry and the Potters, I am not just an avid Wrock Fan, I am an avid Wrock Fangirl... a very noble cause, in my opinion!” This distinction seems to imply a higher level of fandom, as the term “fangirl” usually applies to someone who is almost romantically devoted to a subculture. She also quotes the Whomping Willows song “Wizard Rock Heart Throb,” saying “As we know, wizard rock fans are the sweetest bunch of fans and most of them are girls” This raises a new question for me—to what extent is Wrock a “girl” genre?

The I.W.R.U. forum of the HP Alliance website (http://thehpalliance.org/phpBB/viewforum.php?f=44&sid=b0b8b34f0f61697264c7d8e125459b54) features posts from notable Wrock musicians Whompy (Matt Maggiacomo) of the Whomping Willows and Harry Potter Year 7 (Paul DeGeorge) of Harry and the Potters. Paul’s topic is “How to Book a Rock Show,” which strongly suggests playing in unconventional venues and having your own equipment for what Paul calls “DIY shows.” About getting paid for shows, he says “It’s okay to ask for money, and it’s also okay to play for free.” Matt has a very long post entitled “Why DIY?” in which he states that “Wizard rock is a rare example of a successful DIY movement.” He emphasizes the role of the Internet and Myspace in building the movement, and praises Wrock fans for not focusing on musical ability and being devoted to and participatory in the scene. He also says one extremely interesting thing about Wrock fans that I want to investigate more: “It’s rare that you’ll come across a wizard rock fan who believes himself or herself to be a “bigger” wizard rock fan than other fans. This is probably because wizard rock bands are extremely accessible to fans, and we show our appreciation to ALL of our fans on a consistent basis. Competition among fans is something that plagues virtually every music scene known to humankind – and yet, it’s almost non-existent in wizard rock.” Is this sentiment in opposition with Dinahsaur’s fan/fangirl distinction that I mentioned earlier? In support of DIY recording, he says that “What most bands don’t realize is that all labels, even the smallest indie labels, have some sort of an agenda.” He is optimistic about the power of Wrock DIY, saying that “If enough people sign on to this methodology, the end result could be a legitimate revolution that would shake up the music industry and (maybe) render corporate record labels an obsolete relic of the past.” He frequently reiterates that Wrock fans and musicians have very high levels or interaction, as well as established and new Wrock bands. Finally, Matt and Paul both post on a thread entitled “Self-releasing a CD.”

Monday, October 15, 2007

Fieldnotes

For the first stage of my research, I've gathered some fieldnotes related to the online wizard rock community. While I do plan on attending at least one show and interviewing some scene members, because the online aspect of wizard rock is so important I felt that exploring that realm first would help me fundamentally understand the scene before I began to interact more directly with it.

Facebook Group: I LISTEN TO WIZARD ROCK!

http://brown.facebook.com/group.php?gid=2204889485

The vast majority of discussion board participants are high school girls, though there are some young men and college students involved. There are members from Mexico, Norway, and Iceland. The group has 982 members, which is substantial for a Facebook group. There’s a conversation on the wall about whether or not wrock will become too mainstream after receiving MTV coverage. It’s important that the scene stay “unique.” Most discussion revolves around promoting and mentioning fans’ favorite bands. There are some posts on the board from a member of the Moaning Myrtles. It’s a badge of honor to have seen a lot of live wrock concerts. Some band names send up rock cliches: for example, The Butterbeer Experience and the N. Tonks Project.

Myspace Group: Wizard Rock

http://groups.myspace.com/wizardrock

In group description: “This is a temple of love, no hating allowed. Also, we do not tolerate intolerance!!” 2767 members—it seems like Myspace is more central to the wrock scene than Facebook, possibly because of all the Myspace band pages. Many of the groups also have supplemental Myspace pages with more music on them, which makes wizard rock extremely accessible to young fans without much disposable income. There’s a large thread devoted to new songs on Myspace. The “Favorite muggle musicians” (non-wrock artists) thread is interesting. Lots of hipster indie music, some metal, some 80s. Very little hip-hop and country, no mainstream pop. Overall white-identified semi-alternative feel. Once again, band members are involved in a wrock fan group, even more this time than in the Facebook group.

The Wizrocklopedia

http://wizrocklopedia.com

Some music reviews on the site, but they’re all entirely positive and without ratings. In these reviews, some tracks are described as very emotionally affecting—wizard rock isn’t all a joke. This website held a People’s Choice Awards for wrock—they received over 2000 votes for categories like “Best Holiday Song of 2006,” “Best Instrumental,” and “Best Rap.” Not having encountered wrock rap yet, I check out the Myspace page for the Best Rap winner, DJ Luna Lovegood (http://www.myspace.com/djlovegood). She lists influences like NWA, Black Sabbath, and The Velvet Underground, her sound and vocals are frequently reminiscent of shoegaze (she doesn’t appear to be mostly focused on rap), and the song “Under Your Nose Hermione” reminds me of Peaches. Disparate influences like these appear to be common to wrock artists—there isn’t really a shared idea of “the right influences” like in some genres, though it is standard to claim to be influenced by other wizard rock bands. Mostly other wrock bands on her comments section. The Sectumsempras, winner of the “Best Metal or Goth” award, take their name from a “bloody and violent spell” according to their Myspace (http://www.myspace.com/sectumsempras). Also from their blog: “They’d [The Sectumsempras] like to think they are the darkest maybe not musically, but lyrically within the Wizard Rock genre.” Their techno-goth song “Lamb to the Slaughter” fits this model, with lyrics like “You’re the lamb to be slaughtered for the greater good.” Even though Harry Potter is primarily intended as a children’s book, it has several dark themes and elements, and these themes are reflected in some sectors of its fan culture. I’ve specifically noticed this in fanfiction, which can be graphic and very much for adults and teenagers only. It seems to me like a diverse world like that of the Harry Potter books gives fans many options to identify with different characters and elements of that world, an identification that can then lead to production of fan art in various forms.

Wednesday, October 3, 2007

Some references

Here are a few of the references I'll definitely be consulting for my ethnography:

Spencer, Amy. 2005. DIY: The Rise of Lo-fi Culture. New York: Marion Boyars.

Although this book doesn't directly pertain to wizard rock, I'm hoping that this source will give me a better understanding of the DIY culture that is central to wizard rock.

Kidd, Dustin. 2007. "Harry Potter and the Functions of Popular Culture." The Journal of Popular Culture 40(1):69-89.

This article discusses why Harry Potter fans create a community based on popular culture, the same community that produces wizard rock.

The Wizrocklopedia (anonymous staff member). n.d. "The History of Wizard Rock." http://wizrocklopedia.com/index.php/the-history-of-wizard-rock/

This article from a wizard rock fansite provides a comprehensive history of the genre and some insights from an anonymous scene member as to what the scene "stands for" and accomplishes.

I've also found plenty of fansites, Myspace pages, and mainstream media articles about wizard rock that will give me lots of material to draw from.

Monday, September 24, 2007

Wizard rock rocks

The ethnography topic I'll be exploring in this blog is the wizard rock (also known as wrock) scene. Essentially, wizard rock is music with lyrics related to the world of Harry Potter. Wizard rock bands generally exclusively produce Harry Potter themed music, and often take on the personas of specific characters. For example, the two members of the popular wizard rock band Harry and the Potters perform as Harry Potter in his 4th year of Hogwarts and Harry Potter in his 7th year of Hogwarts. Other well-known wizard rock bands are the Whomping Willows, Draco and the Malfoys (who have a faux-rivalry with Harry and the Potters) and the Remus Lupins. Wizard rock's clever but typically PG-rated lyrics mostly appeal to kids and teenagers, while wizard rock musicians can be children but are generally teenagers and adults. Interestingly, wizard rock is perhaps the only music scene that frequently holds performances in libraries.

Here are some of the research questions I hope to explore over the course of this project:
-Why would an individual musician or group want to entirely focus on Harry Potter for lyrical subject matter? In other words, what is the appeal of the wizard rock scene for musicians?
-Similarly, what draws fans to the scene? Is it solely based on Harry Potter fandom, or are there other aspects of wizard rock that make it attractive to fans?
-How does the wizard rock community operate? What does it value?
-What is the relationship between wizard rock and other genres of music? Specifically, while wizard rock can be overtly influenced by genres ranging from metal to electronic, its deemphasis on musical proficiency and its DIY aspects seem to most strongly connect it to punk.

And now, as a slightly more interesting introduction to wizard rock, here's Harry and the Potters performing their song "Voldemort Can't Stop the Rock" in a library.

Monday, September 17, 2007

Hi!

Welcome to my research blog for Musical Youth Cultures! Now that I have a spiffy website, all I need is something to write about...